Authors and reviews


Today I received a fabulous new review for Foley Russel and That Poor Girl, and naturally I cried while trying to read it out aloud to my hubby.  That’s right, didn’t cry while reading on my own, I had to cry in front of others.  Anyway, it got me to thinking about the relationship between writers and reviewers.

It’s a tenuous relationship.  Less obvious than that between writers and editors or writers and publishers, but a relationship nonetheless.  Still, I’m yet to figure out exactly how it all works.  After all, I’ve read a lot of books that got great reviews and even won awards, but which I thought were nigh on unreadable.  Too wordy, pretentious or abstract for me to actually care about either the story or its characters.  By the same token, I’ve read books which were absolutely bagged by the reviewers but that I truly loved.

I think these discrepancies are proof positive that assessment of writing, like assessment of most art, is almost entirely subjective.  Different people like different things.  Some people adore Picasso’s ‘Blue period’ for example, me…not so much.  It doesn’t mean the art is no good, it just means it’s not for me.  Obviously, the more people who love something, the more likely it is that you will too, the creation has something about it that is generally appealing.

General appeal, or universal popularity, requires a large number of people to actually participate in assessing the work.  That makes reviewers like treasure hunters.  They find things that are as yet undiscovered, and start appraising it, which is a tricky job if you think about it; and I’m well aware that a reviewer’s opinion is not always right.

All that said, reviewers are readers and that’s why their opinion affects me.  I want my readers to love my stories.  I want to feel like I’ve created a little something special for them…and it thrills me when they say I’ve succeeded.


2 responses »

  1. Thank you for your kind mention and I am touched you cried. Well, I don’t want to make people cry, except in the good way of course, which I am assuming happened to you 🙂

    I find myself in the same position many a time, liking things the “experts” hate and find the critic’s choices sometimes “meh”.

    I think that’s one of the reasons I started my blog, I really just wanted to celebrate the children’s books I liked and how they touch my own life without all the literary pretense (which to be honest I couldn’t out on if I wanted to!).

    I wanted to talk about great books the way I would like to learn about them, through how they impact those who have read them.

    I am certainly a reader and you have created something special for me and I hope many, many others.

    Thank you 🙂

    • Hi Stacy, I hope you got my thank you note via email. Something weird happened while I was trying to post it, so I can’t be sure.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s